Bitwise Operators in Python

Bitwise Operators in Python

by Bartosz Zaczyński intermediate python

Watch Now This tutorial has a related video course created by the Real Python team. Watch it together with the written tutorial to deepen your understanding: Binary, Bytes, and Bitwise Operators in Python

Computers store all kinds of information as a stream of binary digits called bits. Whether you’re working with text, images, or videos, they all boil down to ones and zeros. Python’s bitwise operators let you manipulate those individual bits of data at the most granular level.

You can use bitwise operators to implement algorithms such as compression, encryption, and error detection as well as to control physical devices in your Raspberry Pi project or elsewhere. Often, Python isolates you from the underlying bits with high-level abstractions. You’re more likely to find the overloaded flavors of bitwise operators in practice. But when you work with them in their original form, you’ll be surprised by their quirks!

In this tutorial, you’ll learn how to:

  • Use Python bitwise operators to manipulate individual bits
  • Read and write binary data in a platform-agnostic way
  • Use bitmasks to pack information on a single byte
  • Overload Python bitwise operators in custom data types
  • Hide secret messages in digital images

To get the complete source code of the digital watermarking example, and to extract a secret treat hidden in an image, click the link below:

Overview of Python’s Bitwise Operators

Python comes with a few different kinds of operators, such as the arithmetic, logical, and comparison operators. You can think of them as functions that take advantage of a more compact prefix and infix syntax.

Bitwise operators look virtually the same across different programming languages:

Operator Example Meaning
& a & b Bitwise AND
| a | b Bitwise OR
^ a ^ b Bitwise XOR (exclusive OR)
~ ~a Bitwise NOT
<< a << n Bitwise left shift
>> a >> n Bitwise right shift

As you can see, they’re denoted with strange-looking symbols instead of words. This makes them stand out in Python as slightly less verbose than you might be used to seeing. You probably wouldn’t be able to figure out their meaning just by looking at them.

Most of the bitwise operators are binary, which means that they expect two operands to work with, typically referred to as the left operand and the right operand. Bitwise NOT (~) is the only unary bitwise operator since it expects just one operand.

All binary bitwise operators have a corresponding compound operator that performs an augmented assignment:

Operator Example Equivalent to
&= a &= b a = a & b
|= a |= b a = a | b
^= a ^= b a = a ^ b
<<= a <<= n a = a << n
>>= a >>= n a = a >> n

These are shorthand notations for updating the left operand in place.

That’s all there is to Python’s bitwise operator syntax! Now you’re ready to take a closer look at each of the operators to understand where they’re most useful and how you can use them. First, you’ll get a quick refresher on the binary system before looking at two categories of bitwise operators: the bitwise logical operators and the bitwise shift operators.

Binary System in Five Minutes

Before moving on, take a moment to brush up your knowledge of the binary system, which is essential to understanding bitwise operators. If you’re already comfortable with it, then go ahead and jump to the Bitwise Logical Operators section below.

Why Use Binary?

There are an infinite number of ways to represent numbers. Since ancient times, people have developed different notations, such as Roman numerals and Egyptian hieroglyphs. Most modern civilizations use positional notation, which is efficient, flexible, and well suited for doing arithmetic.

A notable feature of any positional system is its base, which represents the number of digits available. People naturally favor the base-ten numeral system, also known as the decimal system, because it plays nicely with counting on fingers.

Computers, on the other hand, treat data as a bunch of numbers expressed in the base-two numeral system, more commonly known as the binary system. Such numbers are composed of only two digits, zero and one.

For example, the binary number 100111002 is equivalent to 15610 in the base-ten system. Because there are ten numerals in the decimal system—zero through nine—it usually takes fewer digits to write the same number in base ten than in base two.

The binary system requires more storage space than the decimal system but is much less complicated to implement in hardware. While you need more building blocks, they’re easier to make, and there are fewer types of them. That’s like breaking down your code into more modular and reusable pieces.

More importantly, however, the binary system is perfect for electronic devices, which translate digits into different voltage levels. Because voltage likes to drift up and down due to various kinds of noise, you want to keep sufficient distance between consecutive voltages. Otherwise, the signal might end up distorted.

By employing only two states, you make the system more reliable and resistant to noise. Alternatively, you could jack up the voltage, but that would also increase the power consumption, which you definitely want to avoid.

How Does Binary Work?

Imagine for a moment that you had only two fingers to count on. You could count a zero, a one, and a two. But when you ran out of fingers, you’d need to note how many times you had already counted to two and then start over until you reached two again:

Decimal Fingers Eights Fours Twos Ones Binary
010 0 0 0 0 02
110 ☝️ 0 0 0 1 12
210 ✌️ 0 0 1 0 102
310 ✌️+☝️ 0 0 1 1 112
410 ✌️✌️ 0 1 0 0 1002
510 ✌️✌️+☝️ 0 1 0 1 1012
610 ✌️✌️+✌️ 0 1 1 0 1102
710 ✌️✌️+✌️+☝️ 0 1 1 1 1112
810 ✌️✌️✌️✌️ 1 0 0 0 10002
910 ✌️✌️✌️✌️+☝️ 1 0 0 1 10012
1010 ✌️✌️✌️✌️+✌️ 1 0 1 0 10102
1110 ✌️✌️✌️✌️+✌️+☝️ 1 0 1 1 10112
1210 ✌️✌️✌️✌️+✌️✌️ 1 1 0 0 11002
1310 ✌️✌️✌️✌️+✌️✌️+☝️ 1 1 0 1 11012

Every time you wrote down another pair of fingers, you’d also need to group them by powers of two, which is the base of the system. For example, to count up to thirteen, you would have to use both of your fingers six times and then use one more finger. Your fingers could be arranged as one eight, one four, and one one.

These powers of two correspond to digit positions in a binary number and tell you exactly which bits to switch on. They grow right to left, starting at the least-significant bit, which determines if the number is even or odd.

Positional notation is like the odometer in your car: Once a digit in a particular position reaches its maximum value, which is one in the binary system, it rolls over to zero and the one carries over to the left. This can have a cascading effect if there are already some ones to the left of the digit.

How Computers Use Binary

Now that you know the basic principles of the binary system and why computers use it, you’re ready to learn how they represent data with it.

Before any piece of information can be reproduced in digital form, you have to break it down into numbers and then convert them to the binary system. For example, plain text can be thought of as a string of characters. You could assign an arbitrary number to each character or pick an existing character encoding such as ASCII, ISO-8859-1, or UTF-8.

In Python, strings are represented as arrays of Unicode code points. To reveal their ordinal values, call ord() on each of the characters:

Python
>>> [ord(character) for character in "€uro"]
[8364, 117, 114, 111]

The resulting numbers uniquely identify the text characters within the Unicode space, but they’re shown in decimal form. You want to rewrite them using binary digits:

Character Decimal Code Point Binary Code Point
836410 100000101011002
u 11710 11101012
r 11410 11100102
o 11110 11011112

Notice that bit-length, which is the number of binary digits, varies greatly across the characters. The euro sign () requires fourteen bits, while the rest of the characters can comfortably fit on seven bits.

Variable bit-lengths are problematic. If you were to put those binary numbers next to one another on an optical disc, for example, then you’d end up with a long stream of bits without clear boundaries between the characters:

100000101011001110101111001011011112

One way of knowing how to interpret this information is to designate fixed-length bit patterns for all characters. In modern computing, the smallest unit of information, called an octet or a byte, comprises eight bits that can store 256 distinct values.

You can pad your binary code points with leading zeros to express them in terms of bytes:

Character Decimal Code Point Binary Code Point
836410 00100000 101011002
u 11710 00000000 011101012
r 11410 00000000 011100102
o 11110 00000000 011011112

Now each character takes two bytes, or 16 bits. In total, your original text almost doubled in size, but at least it’s encoded reliably.

You can use Huffman coding to find unambiguous bit patterns for every character in a particular text or use a more suitable character encoding. For example, to save space, UTF-8 intentionally favors Latin letters over symbols that you’re less likely to find in an English text:

Python
>>> len("€uro".encode("utf-8"))
6

Encoded according to the UTF-8 standard, the entire text takes six bytes. Since UTF-8 is a superset of ASCII, the letters u, r, and o occupy one byte each, whereas the euro symbol takes three bytes in this encoding:

Python
>>> for char in "€uro":
...     print(char, len(char.encode("utf-8")))
...
€ 3
u 1
r 1
o 1

Other types of information can be digitized similarly to text. Raster images are made of pixels, with every pixel having channels that represent color intensities as numbers. Sound waveforms contain numbers corresponding to air pressure at a given sampling interval. Three-dimensional models are built from geometric shapes defined by their vertices, and so forth.

At the end of the day, everything is a number.

Bitwise Logical Operators

You can use bitwise operators to perform Boolean logic on individual bits. That’s analogous to using logical operators such as and, or, and not, but on a bit level. The similarities between bitwise and logical operators go beyond that.

It’s possible to evaluate Boolean expressions with bitwise operators instead of logical operators, but such overuse is generally discouraged. If you’re interested in the details, then you can expand the box below to find out more.

The ordinary way of specifying compound Boolean expressions in Python is to use the logical operators that connect adjacent predicates, like this:

Python
if age >= 18 and not is_self_excluded:
    print("You can gamble")

Here, you check if the user is at least eighteen years old and if they haven’t opted out of gambling. You can rewrite that condition using bitwise operators:

Python
if age >= 18 & ~is_self_excluded:
    print("You can gamble")

Although this expression is syntactically correct, there are a few problems with it. First, it’s arguably less readable. Second, it doesn’t work as expected for all groups of data. You can demonstrate that by choosing specific operand values:

Python
>>> age = 18
>>> is_self_excluded = True
>>> age >= 18 & ~is_self_excluded  # Bitwise logical operators
True
>>> age >= 18 and not is_self_excluded  # Logical operators
False

The expression made of the bitwise operators evaluates to True, while the same expression built from the logical operators evaluates to False. That’s because bitwise operators take precedence over the comparison operators, changing how the whole expression is interpreted:

Python
>>> age >= (18 & ~is_self_excluded)
True

It’s as if someone put implicit parentheses around the wrong operands. To fix this, you can put explicit parentheses, which will enforce the correct order of evaluation:

Python
>>> (age >= 18) & ~is_self_excluded
0

However, you no longer get a Boolean result. Python bitwise operators were designed primarily to work with integers, so their operands automatically get casted if needed. This may not always be possible, though.

While you can use truthy and falsy integers in a Boolean context, it’s a known antipattern that can cost you long hours of unnecessary debugging. You’re better off following the Zen of Python to save yourself the trouble.

Last but not least, you may deliberately want to use bitwise operators to disable the short-circuit evaluation of Boolean expressions. Expressions using logical operators are evaluated lazily from left to right. In other words, the evaluation stops as soon as the result of the entire expression is known:

Python
>>> def call(x):
...     print(f"call({x=})")
...     return x
...
>>> call(False) or call(True)  # Both operands evaluated
call(x=False)
call(x=True)
True
>>> call(True) or call(False)  # Only the left operand evaluated
call(x=True)
True

In the second example, the right operand isn’t called at all because the value of the entire expression has already been determined by the value of the left operand. No matter what the right operand is, it won’t affect the result, so there’s no point in calling it unless you rely on side effects.

There are idioms, such as falling back to a default value, that take advantage of this peculiarity:

Python
>>> (1 + 1) or "default"  # The left operand is truthy
2
>>> (1 - 1) or "default"  # The left operand is falsy
'default'

A Boolean expression takes the value of the last evaluated operand. The operand becomes truthy or falsy inside the expression but retains its original type and value afterward. In particular, a positive integer on the left gets propagated, while a zero gets discarded.

Unlike their logical counterparts, bitwise operators are evaluated eagerly:

Python
>>> call(True) | call(False)
call(x=True)
call(x=False)
True

Even though knowing the left operand is sufficient to determine the value of the entire expression, all operands are always evaluated unconditionally.

Unless you have a strong reason and know what you’re doing, you should use bitwise operators only for controlling bits. It’s too easy to get it wrong otherwise. In most cases, you’ll want to pass integers as arguments to the bitwise operators.

Bitwise AND

The bitwise AND operator (&) performs logical conjunction on the corresponding bits of its operands. For each pair of bits occupying the same position in the two numbers, it returns a one only when both bits are switched on:

Animation depicting the bitwise AND operator

The resulting bit pattern is an intersection of the operator’s arguments. It has two bits turned on in the positions where both operands are ones. In all other places, at least one of the inputs has a zero bit.

Arithmetically, this is equivalent to a product of two bit values. You can calculate the bitwise AND of numbers a and b by multiplying their bits at every index i:

The arithmetic formula for the bitwise AND operator

Here’s a concrete example:

Expression Binary Value Decimal Value
a 100111002 15610
b 1101002 5210
a & b 101002 2010

A one multiplied by one gives one, but anything multiplied by zero will always result in zero. Alternatively, you can take the minimum of the two bits in each pair. Notice that when operands have unequal bit-lengths, the shorter one is automatically padded with zeros to the left.

Bitwise OR

The bitwise OR operator (|) performs logical disjunction. For each corresponding pair of bits, it returns a one if at least one of them is switched on:

Animation depicting the bitwise OR operator

The resulting bit pattern is a union of the operator’s arguments. It has five bits turned on where either of the operands has a one. Only a combination of two zeros gives a zero in the final output.

The arithmetic behind it is a combination of a sum and a product of the bit values. To calculate the bitwise OR of numbers a and b, you need to apply the following formula to their bits at every index i:

The arithmetic formula for the bitwise OR operator

Here’s a tangible example:

Expression Binary Value Decimal Value
a 100111002 15610
b 1101002 5210
a | b 101111002 18810

It’s almost like a sum of two bits but clamped at the higher end so that it never exceeds the value of one. You could also take the maximum of the two bits in each pair to get the same result.

Bitwise XOR

Unlike bitwise AND, OR, and NOT, the bitwise XOR operator (^) doesn’t have a logical counterpart in Python. However, you can simulate it by building on top of the existing operators:

Python
def xor(a, b):
    return (a and not b) or (not a and b)

It evaluates two mutually exclusive conditions and tells you whether exactly one of them is met. For example, a person can be either a minor or an adult, but not both at the same time. Conversely, it’s not possible for a person to be neither a minor nor an adult. The choice is mandatory.

The name XOR stands for “exclusive or” since it performs exclusive disjunction on the bit pairs. In other words, every bit pair must contain opposing bit values to produce a one:

Animation depicting the bitwise XOR operator

Visually, it’s a symmetric difference of the operator’s arguments. There are three bits switched on in the result where both numbers have different bit values. Bits in the remaining positions cancel out because they’re the same.

Similarly to the bitwise OR operator, the arithmetic of XOR involves a sum. However, while the bitwise OR clamps values at one, the XOR operator wraps them around with a sum modulo two:

The arithmetic formula for the bitwise XOR operator

Modulo is a function of two numbers—the dividend and the divisor—that performs a division and returns its remainder. In Python, there’s a built-in modulo operator denoted with the percent sign (%).

Once again, you can confirm the formula by looking at an example:

Expression Binary Value Decimal Value
a 100111002 15610
b 1101002 5210
a ^ b 101010002 16810

The sum of two zeros or two ones yields a whole number when divided by two, so the result has a remainder of zero. However, when you divide the sum of two different bit values by two, you get a fraction with a remainder of one. A more straightforward formula for the XOR operator is the difference between the maximum and the minimum of both bits in each pair.

Bitwise NOT

The last of the bitwise logical operators is the bitwise NOT operator (~), which expects just one argument, making it the only unary bitwise operator. It performs logical negation on a given number by flipping all of its bits:

Animation depicting the bitwise NOT operator

The inverted bits are a complement to one, which turns zeros into ones and ones into zeros. It can be expressed arithmetically as the subtraction of individual bit values from one:

The arithmetic formula for the bitwise NOT operator

Here’s an example showing one of the numbers used before:

Expression Binary Value Decimal Value
a 100111002 15610
~a 11000112 9910

While the bitwise NOT operator seems to be the most straightforward of them all, you need to exercise extreme caution when using it in Python. Everything you’ve read so far is based on the assumption that numbers are represented with unsigned integers.

Although there are ways to simulate unsigned integers, Python doesn’t support them natively. That means all numbers have an implicit sign attached to them whether you specify one or not. This shows when you do a bitwise NOT of any number:

Python
>>> ~156
-157

Instead of the expected 9910, you get a negative value! The reason for this will become clear once you learn about the various binary number representations. For now, the quick-fix solution is to take advantage of the bitwise AND operator:

Python
>>> ~156 & 255
99

That’s a perfect example of a bitmask, which you’ll explore in one of the upcoming sections.

Bitwise Shift Operators

Bitwise shift operators are another kind of tool for bit manipulation. They let you move the bits around, which will be handy for creating bitmasks later on. In the past, they were often used to improve the speed of certain mathematical operations.

Left Shift

The bitwise left shift operator (<<) moves the bits of its first operand to the left by the number of places specified in its second operand. It also takes care of inserting enough zero bits to fill the gap that arises on the right edge of the new bit pattern:

Animation depicting the left shift operator

Shifting a single bit to the left by one place doubles its value. For example, instead of a two, the bit will indicate a four after the shift. Moving it two places to the left will quadruple the resulting value. When you add up all the bits in a given number, you’ll notice that it also gets doubled with every place shifted:

Expression Binary Value Decimal Value
a 1001112 3910
a << 1 10011102 7810
a << 2 100111002 15610
a << 3 1001110002 31210

In general, shifting bits to the left corresponds to multiplying the number by a power of two, with an exponent equal to the number of places shifted:

The arithmetic formula for the left shift operator

The left shift used to be a popular optimization technique because bit shifting is a single instruction and is cheaper to calculate than exponent or product. Today, however, compilers and interpreters, including Python’s, are quite capable of optimizing your code behind the scenes.

On paper, the bit pattern resulting from a left shift becomes longer by as many places as you shift it. That’s also true for Python in general because of how it handles integers. However, in most practical cases, you’ll want to constrain the length of a bit pattern to be a multiple of eight, which is the standard byte length.

For example, if you’re working with a single byte, then shifting it to the left should discard all the bits that go beyond its left boundary:

Animation depicting the left shift operator with a bitmask

It’s sort of like looking at an unbounded stream of bits through a fixed-length window. There are a few tricks that let you do this in Python. For example, you can apply a bitmask with the bitwise AND operator:

Python
>>> 39 << 3
312
>>> (39 << 3) & 255
56

Shifting 3910 by three places to the left returns a number higher than the maximum value that you can store on a single byte. It takes nine bits, whereas a byte has only eight. To chop off that one extra bit on the left, you can apply a bitmask with the appropriate value. If you’d like to keep more or fewer bits, then you’ll need to modify the mask value accordingly.

Right Shift

The bitwise right shift operator (>>) is analogous to the left one, but instead of moving bits to the left, it pushes them to the right by the specified number of places. The rightmost bits always get dropped:

Animation depicting the right shift operator

Every time you shift a bit to the right by one position, you halve its underlying value. Moving the same bit by two places to the right produces a quarter of the original value, and so on. When you add up all the individual bits, you’ll see that the same rule applies to the number they represent:

Expression Binary Value Decimal Value
a 100111012 15710
a >> 1 10011102 7810
a >> 2 1001112 3910
a >> 3 100112 1910

Halving an odd number such as 15710 would produce a fraction. To get rid of it, the right shift operator automatically floors the result. It’s virtually the same as a floor division by a power of two:

The arithmetic formula for the right shift operator

Again, the exponent corresponds to the number of places shifted to the right. In Python, you can leverage a dedicated operator to perform a floor division:

Python
>>> 5 >> 1  # Bitwise right shift
2
>>> 5 // 2  # Floor division (integer division)
2
>>> 5 / 2   # Floating-point division
2.5

The bitwise right shift operator and the floor division operator both work the same way, even for negative numbers. However, the floor division lets you choose any divisor and not just a power of two. Using the bitwise right shift was a common way of improving the performance of some arithmetic divisions.

Just like with the left shift operator, the bit pattern changes its size after a right shift. While moving bits to the right makes the binary sequence shorter, it usually won’t matter because you can put as many zeros in front of a bit sequence as you like without changing the value. For example, 1012 is the same as 01012, and so is 000001012, provided that you’re dealing with nonnegative numbers.

Sometimes you’ll want to keep a given bit-length after doing a right shift to align it against another value or to fit in somewhere. You can do that by applying a bitmask:

Animation depicting the right shift operator with a bitmask

It carves out only those bits you’re interested in and fills the bit pattern with leading zeros if necessary.

The handling of negative numbers in Python is slightly different from the traditional approach to bitwise shifting. In the next section, you’ll examine this in more detail.

Arithmetic vs Logical Shift

You can further categorize the bitwise shift operators as arithmetic and logical shift operators. While Python only lets you do the arithmetic shift, it’s worthwhile to know how other programming languages implement the bitwise shift operators to avoid confusion and surprises.

This distinction comes from the way they handle the sign bit, which ordinarily lies at the far left edge of a signed binary sequence. In practice, it’s relevant only to the right shift operator, which can cause a number to flip its sign, leading to integer overflow.

Conventionally, a turned-on sign bit indicates negative numbers, which helps keep the arithmetic properties of a binary sequence:

Decimal Value Signed Binary Value Sign Bit Sign Meaning
-10010 100111002 1 - Negative number
2810 000111002 0 + Positive number or zero

Looking from the left at these two binary sequences, you can see that their first bit carries the sign information, while the remaining part consists of the magnitude bits, which are the same for both numbers.

A logical right shift, also known as an unsigned right shift or a zero-fill right shift, moves the entire binary sequence, including the sign bit, and fills the resulting gap on the left with zeros:

Animation depicting the logical right shift operator

Notice how the information about the sign of the number is lost. Regardless of the original sign, it’ll always produce a nonnegative integer because the sign bit gets replaced by zero. As long as you aren’t interested in the numeric values, a logical right shift can be useful in processing low-level binary data.

However, because signed binary numbers are typically stored on a fixed-length bit sequence in most languages, it can make the result wrap around the extreme values. You can see this in an interactive Java Shell tool:

Java
jshell> -100 >>> 1
$1 ==> 2147483598

The resulting number changes its sign from negative to positive, but it also overflows, ending up very close to Java’s maximum integer:

Java
jshell> Integer.MAX_VALUE
$2 ==> 2147483647

This number may seem arbitrary at first glance, but it’s directly related to the number of bits that Java allocates for the Integer data type:

Java
jshell> Integer.toBinaryString(-100)
$3 ==> "11111111111111111111111110011100"

It uses 32 bits to store signed integers in two’s complement representation. When you take the sign bit out, you’re left with 31 bits, whose maximum decimal value is equal to 231 - 1, or 214748364710.

Python, on the other hand, stores integers as if there were an infinite number of bits at your disposal. Consequently, a logical right shift operator wouldn’t be well defined in pure Python, so it’s missing from the language. You can still simulate it, though.

One way of doing so is to take advantage of the unsigned data types available in C that are exposed through the built-in ctypes module:

Python
>>> from ctypes import c_uint32 as unsigned_int32
>>> unsigned_int32(-100).value >> 1
2147483598

They let you pass in a negative number but don’t attach any special meaning to the sign bit. It’s treated like the rest of the magnitude bits.

While there are only a few predefined unsigned integer types in C, which differ in bit-length, you can create a custom function in Python to handle arbitrary bit-lengths:

Python
>>> def logical_rshift(signed_integer, places, num_bits=32):
...     unsigned_integer = signed_integer % (1 << num_bits)
...     return unsigned_integer >> places
...
>>> logical_rshift(-100, 1)
2147483598

This converts a signed bit sequence to an unsigned one and then performs the regular arithmetic right shift.

However, since bit sequences in Python aren’t fixed in length, they don’t really have a sign bit. Moreover, they don’t use the traditional two’s complement representation like in C or Java. To mitigate that, you can take advantage of the modulo operation, which will keep the original bit patterns for positive integers while appropriately wrapping around the negative ones.

An arithmetic right shift (>>), sometimes called the signed right shift operator, maintains the sign of a number by replicating its sign bit before moving bits to the right:

Animation depicting the arithmetic right shift operator

In other words, it fills the gap on the left with whatever the sign bit was. Combined with the two’s complement representation of signed binary, this results in an arithmetically correct value. Regardless of whether the number is positive or negative, an arithmetic right shift is equivalent to floor division.

As you’re about to find out, Python doesn’t always store integers in plain two’s complement binary. Instead, it follows a custom adaptive strategy that works like sign-magnitude with an unlimited number of bits. It converts numbers back and forth between their internal representation and two’s complement to mimic the standard behavior of the arithmetic shift.

Binary Number Representations

You’ve experienced firsthand the lack of unsigned data types in Python when using the bitwise negation (~) and the right shift operator (>>). You’ve seen hints about the unusual approach to storing integers in Python, which makes handling negative numbers tricky. To use bitwise operators effectively, you need to know about the various representations of numbers in binary.

Unsigned Integers

In programming languages like C, you choose whether to use the signed or unsigned flavor of a given numeric type. Unsigned data types are more suitable when you know for sure that you’ll never need to deal with negative numbers. By allocating that one extra bit, which would otherwise serve as a sign bit, you practically double the range of available values.

It also makes things a little safer by increasing the maximum limit before an overflow happens. However, overflows happen only with fixed bit-lengths, so they’re irrelevant to Python, which doesn’t have such constraints.

The quickest way to get a taste of the unsigned numeric types in Python is to use the previously mentioned ctypes module:

Python
>>> from ctypes import c_uint8 as unsigned_byte
>>> unsigned_byte(-42).value
214

Since there’s no sign bit in such integers, all their bits represent the magnitude of a number. Passing a negative number forces Python to reinterpret the bit pattern as if it had only the magnitude bits.

Signed Integers

The sign of a number has only two states. If you ignore zero for a moment, then it can be either positive or negative, which translates nicely to the binary system. Yet there are a few alternative ways to represent signed integers in binary, each with its own pros and cons.

Probably the most straightforward one is the sign-magnitude, which builds naturally on top of unsigned integers. When a binary sequence is interpreted as sign-magnitude, the most significant bit plays the role of a sign bit, while the rest of the bits work the same as usual:

Binary Sequence Sign-Magnitude Value Unsigned Value
001010102 4210 4210
101010102 -4210 17010

A zero on the leftmost bit indicates a positive (+) number, and a one indicates a negative (-) number. Notice that a sign bit doesn’t contribute to the number’s absolute value in sign-magnitude representation. It’s there only to let you flip the sign of the remaining bits.

Why the leftmost bit?

It keeps bit indexing intact, which, in turn, helps maintain backward compatibility of the bit weights used to calculate the decimal value of a binary sequence. However, not everything about sign-magnitude is so great.

The range of values that you can store in a sign-magnitude bit pattern is symmetrical. But it also means that you end up with two ways to convey zero:

Binary Sequence Sign-Magnitude Value Unsigned Value
000000002 +010 010
100000002 -010 12810

Zero doesn’t technically have a sign, but there’s no way not to include one in sign-magnitude. While having an ambiguous zero isn’t ideal in most cases, it’s not the worst part of the story. The biggest downside of this method is cumbersome binary arithmetic.

When you apply standard binary arithmetic to numbers stored in sign-magnitude, it may not give you the expected results. For example, adding two numbers with the same magnitude but opposite signs won’t make them cancel out:

Expression Binary Sequence Sign-Magnitude Value
a 001010102 4210
b 101010102 -4210
a + b 110101002 -8410

The sum of 42 and -42 doesn’t produce zero. Also, the carryover bit can sometimes propagate from magnitude to the sign bit, inverting the sign and yielding an unexpected result.

To address these problems, some of the early computers employed one’s complement representation. The idea was to change how decimal numbers are mapped to particular binary sequences so that they can be added up correctly. For a deeper dive into one’s complement, you can expand the section below.

In one’s complement, positive numbers are the same as in sign-magnitude, but negative numbers are obtained by flipping the positive number’s bits using a bitwise NOT:

Positive Sequence Negative Sequence Magnitude Value
000000002 111111112 ±010
000000012 111111102 ±110
000000102 111111012 ±210
011111112 100000002 ±12710

This preserves the original meaning of the sign bit, so positive numbers still begin with a binary zero, while negative ones start with a binary one. Likewise, the range of values remains symmetrical and continues to have two ways to represent zero. However, the binary sequences of negative numbers in one’s complement are arranged in reverse order as compared to sign-magnitude:

One’s Complement Sign-Magnitude Decimal Value
111111112 100000002 -010
111111102 100000012 -110
111111012 100000102 -210
100000102 111111012 -12510
100000012 111111102 -12610
100000002 111111112 -12710

Thanks to that, you can now add two numbers more reliably because the sign bit doesn’t need special treatment. If a carryover originates from the sign bit, it’s fed back at the right edge of the binary sequence instead of just being dropped. This ensures the correct result.

Nevertheless, modern computers don’t use one’s complement to represent integers because there’s an even better way called two’s complement. By applying a small modification, you can eliminate double zero and simplify the binary arithmetic in one go. To explore two’s complement in more detail, you can expand the section below.

When finding bit sequences of negative values in two’s complement, the trick is to add one to the result after negating the bits:

Positive Sequence One’s Complement (NOT) Two’s Complement (NOT+1)
000000002 111111112 000000002
000000012 111111102 111111112
000000102 111111012 111111102
011111112 100000002 100000012

This pushes the bit sequences of negative numbers down by one place, eliminating the notorious minus zero. A more useful minus one will take over its bit pattern instead.

As a side effect, the range of available values in two’s complement becomes asymmetrical, with a lower bound that’s a power of two and an odd upper bound. For example, an 8-bit signed integer will let you store numbers from -12810 to 12710 in two’s complement:

Two’s Complement One’s Complement Decimal Value
100000002 N/A -12810
100000012 100000002 -12710
100000102 100000012 -12610
111111102 111111012 -210
111111112 111111102 -110
N/A 111111112 -010
000000002 000000002 010
000000012 000000012 110
000000102 000000102 210
011111112 011111112 12710

Another way to put it is that the most significant bit carries both the sign and part of the number magnitude:

Bit 7 Bit 6 Bit 5 Bit 4 Bit 3 Bit 2 Bit 1 Bit 0
-27 26 25 24 23 22 21 20
-128 64 32 16 8 4 2 1

Notice the minus sign next to the leftmost bit weight. Deriving a decimal value from a binary sequence like that is only a matter of adding appropriate columns. For example, the value of 110101102 in 8-bit two’s complement representation is the same as the sum: -12810 + 6410 + 1610 + 410 + 210 = -4210.

With the two’s complement representation, you no longer need to worry about the carryover bit unless you want to use it as an overflow detection mechanism, which is kind of neat.

There are a few other variants of signed number representations, but they’re not as popular.

Floating-Point Numbers

The IEEE 754 standard defines a binary representation for real numbers consisting of the sign, exponent, and mantissa bits. Without getting into too many technical details, you can think of it as the scientific notation for binary numbers. The decimal point “floats” around to accommodate a varying number of significant figures, except it’s a binary point.

Two data types conforming to that standard are widely supported:

  1. Single precision: 1 sign bit, 8 exponent bits, 23 mantissa bits
  2. Double precision: 1 sign bit, 11 exponent bits, 52 mantissa bits

Python’s float data type is equivalent to the double-precision type. Note that some applications require more or fewer bits. For example, the OpenEXR image format takes advantage of half precision to represent pixels with a high dynamic range of colors at a reasonable file size.

The number Pi (π) has the following binary representation in single precision when rounded to five decimal places:

Sign Exponent Mantissa
02 100000002 .100100100001111110100002

The sign bit works just like with integers, so zero denotes a positive number. For the exponent and mantissa, however, different rules can apply depending on a few edge cases.

First, you need to convert them from binary to the decimal form:

  • Exponent: 12810
  • Mantissa: 2-1 + 2-4 + … + 2-19 = 29926110/52428810 ≈ 0.57079510

The exponent is stored as an unsigned integer, but to account for negative values, it usually has a bias equal to 12710 in single precision. You need to subtract it to recover the actual exponent.

Mantissa bits represent a fraction, so they correspond to negative powers of two. Additionally, you need to add one to the mantissa because it assumes an implicit leading bit before the radix point in this particular case.

Putting it all together, you arrive at the following formula to convert a floating-point binary number into a decimal one:

The Formula for Floating-Point Binary to Decimal Conversion

When you substitute the variables for the actual values in the example above, you’ll be able to decipher the bit pattern of a floating-point number stored in single precision:

The Number Pi in Floating-Point Binary

There it is, granted that Pi has been rounded to five decimal places. You’ll learn how to display such numbers in binary later on.

Fixed-Point Numbers

While floating-point numbers are a good fit for engineering purposes, they fail in monetary calculations due to their limited precision. For example, some numbers with a finite representation in decimal notation have only an infinite representation in binary. That often results in a rounding error, which can accumulate over time:

Python
>>> 0.1 + 0.2
0.30000000000000004

In such cases, you’re better off using Python’s decimal module, which implements fixed-point arithmetic and lets you specify where to put the decimal point on a given bit-length. For example, you can tell it how many digits you want to preserve:

Python
>>> from decimal import Decimal, localcontext
>>> with localcontext() as context:
...     context.prec = 5  # Number of digits
...     print(Decimal("123.456") * 1)
...
123.46

However, it includes all digits, not just the fractional ones.

If you can’t or don’t want to use a fixed-point data type, a straightforward way to reliably store currency values is to scale the amounts to the smallest unit, such as cents, and represent them with integers.

Integers in Python

In the old days of programming, computer memory was at a premium. Therefore, languages would give you pretty granular control over how many bytes to allocate for your data. Let’s take a quick peek at a few integer types from C as an example:

Type Size Minimum Value Maximum Value
char 1 byte -128 127
short 2 bytes -32,768 32,767
int 4 bytes -2,147,483,648 2,147,483,647
long 8 bytes -9,223,372,036,854,775,808 9,223,372,036,854,775,807

These values might vary from platform to platform. However, such an abundance of numeric types allows you to arrange data in memory compactly. Remember that these don’t even include unsigned types!

On the other end of the spectrum are languages such as JavaScript, which have just one numeric type to rule them all. While this is less confusing for beginning programmers, it comes at the price of increased memory consumption, reduced processing efficiency, and decreased precision.

When talking about bitwise operators, it’s essential to understand how Python handles integer numbers. After all, you’ll use these operators mainly to work with integers. There are a couple of wildly different representations of integers in Python that depend on their values.

Interned Integers

In CPython, very small integers between -510 and 25610 are interned in a global cache to gain some performance because numbers in that range are commonly used. In practice, whenever you refer to one of those values, which are singletons created at the interpreter startup, Python will always provide the same instance:

Python
>>> a = 256
>>> b = 256
>>> a is b
True
>>> print(id(a), id(b), sep="\n")
94050914330336
94050914330336

Both variables have the same identity because they refer to the exact same object in memory. That’s typical of reference types but not immutable values such as integers. However, when you go beyond that range of cached values, Python will start creating distinct copies during variable assignment:

Python
>>> a = 257
>>> b = 257
>>> a is b
False
>>> print(id(a), id(b), sep="\n")
140282370939376
140282370939120

Despite having equal values, these variables point to separate objects now. But don’t let that fool you. Python will occasionally jump in and optimize your code behind the scenes. For example, it’ll cache a number that occurs on the same line multiple times regardless of its value:

Python
>>> a = 257
>>> b = 257
>>> print(id(a), id(b), sep="\n")
140258768039856
140258768039728
>>> print(id(257), id(257), sep="\n")
140258768039760
140258768039760

Variables a and b are independent objects because they reside at different memory locations, while the numbers used literally in print() are, in fact, the same object.

Interestingly, there’s a similar string interning mechanism in Python, which kicks in for short texts comprised of ASCII letters only. It helps speed up dictionary lookups by allowing their keys to be compared by memory addresses, or C pointers, instead of by the individual string characters.

Fixed-Precision Integers

Integers that you’re most likely to find in Python will leverage the C signed long data type. They use the classic two’s complement binary representation on a fixed number of bits. The exact bit-length will depend on your hardware platform, operating system, and Python interpreter version.

Modern computers typically use 64-bit architecture, so this would translate to decimal numbers between -263 and 263 - 1. You can check the maximum value of a fixed-precision integer in Python in the following way:

Python
>>> import sys
>>> sys.maxsize
9223372036854775807

It’s huge! Roughly 9 million times the number of stars in our galaxy, so it should suffice for everyday use. While the maximum value that you could squeeze out of the unsigned long type in C is even bigger, on the order of 1019, integers in Python have no theoretical limit. To allow this, numbers that don’t fit on a fixed-length bit sequence are stored differently in memory.

Arbitrary-Precision Integers

Do you remember that popular K-pop song “Gangnam Style” that became a worldwide hit in 2012? The YouTube video was the first to break a billion views. Soon after that, so many people had watched the video that it made the view counter overflow. YouTube had no choice but to upgrade their counter from 32-bit signed integers to 64-bit ones.

That might give plenty of headroom for a view counter, but there are even bigger numbers that aren’t uncommon in real life, notably in the scientific world. Nonetheless, Python can deal with them effortlessly:

Python
>>> from math import factorial
>>> factorial(42)
1405006117752879898543142606244511569936384000000000

This number has fifty-two decimal digits. It would take at least 170 bits to represent it in binary with the traditional approach:

Python
>>> factorial(42).bit_length()
170

Since they’re well over the limits that any of the C types have to offer, such astronomical numbers are converted into a sign-magnitude positional system, whose base is 230. Yes, you read that correctly. Whereas you have ten fingers, Python has over a billion!

Again, this may vary depending on the platform you’re currently using. When in doubt, you can double-check:

Python
>>> import sys
>>> sys.int_info
sys.int_info(bits_per_digit=30, sizeof_digit=4)

This will tell you how many bits are used per digit and what the size in bytes is of the underlying C structure. To get the same namedtuple in Python 2, you’d refer to the sys.long_info attribute instead.

While this conversion between fixed- and arbitrary-precision integers is done seamlessly under the hood in Python 3, there was a time when things were more explicit. For more information, you can expand the box below.

In the past, Python explicitly defined two distinct integer types:

  1. Plain integer
  2. Long integer

The first one was modeled after the C signed long type, which typically occupied 32 or 64 bits and offered a limited range of values:

Python
>>> # Python 2
>>> import sys
>>> sys.maxint
9223372036854775807
>>> type(sys.maxint)
<type 'int'>

For bigger numbers, you were supposed to use the second type that didn’t come with a limit. Python would automatically promote plain integers to long ones if needed:

Python
>>> # Python 2
>>> import sys
>>> sys.maxint + 1
9223372036854775808L
>>> type(sys.maxint + 1)
<type 'long'>

This feature prevented the integer overflow error. Notice the letter L at the end of a literal, which could be used to enforce the given type by hand:

Python
>>> # Python 2
>>> type(42)
<type 'int'>
>>> type(42L)
<type 'long'>

Eventually, both types were unified so that you wouldn’t have to think about it anymore.

Such a representation eliminates integer overflow errors and gives the illusion of infinite bit-length, but it requires significantly more memory. Additionally, performing bignum arithmetic is slower than with fixed precision because it can’t run directly in hardware without an intermediate layer of emulation.

Another challenge is keeping a consistent behavior of the bitwise operators across alternative integer types, which is crucial in handling the sign bit. Recall that fixed-precision integers in Python use the standard two’s complement representation from C, while large integers use sign-magnitude.

To mitigate that difference, Python will do the necessary binary conversion for you. It might change how a number is represented before and after applying a bitwise operator. Here’s a relevant comment from the CPython source code, which explains this in more detail:

Bitwise operations for negative numbers operate as though on a two’s complement representation. So convert arguments from sign-magnitude to two’s complement, and convert the result back to sign-magnitude at the end. (Source)

In other words, negative numbers are treated as two’s complement bit sequences when you apply the bitwise operators on them, even though the result will be presented to you in sign-magnitude form. There are ways to emulate the sign bit and some of the unsigned types in Python, though.

Bit Strings in Python

You’re welcome to use pen and paper throughout the rest of this article. It may even serve as a great exercise! However, at some point, you’ll want to verify whether your binary sequences or bit strings correspond to the expected numbers in Python. Here’s how.

Converting int to Binary

To reveal the bits making up an integer number in Python, you can print a formatted string literal, which optionally lets you specify the number of leading zeros to display:

Python
>>> print(f"{42:b}")  # Print 42 in binary
101010
>>> print(f"{42:032b}")  # Print 42 in binary on 32 zero-padded digits
00000000000000000000000000101010

Alternatively, you can call bin() with the number as an argument:

Python
>>> bin(42)
'0b101010'

This global built-in function returns a string consisting of a binary literal, which starts with the prefix 0b and is followed by ones and zeros. It always shows the minimum number of digits without the leading zeros.

You can use such literals verbatim in your code, too:

Python
>>> age = 0b101010
>>> print(age)
42

Other integer literals available in Python are the hexadecimal and octal ones, which you can obtain with the hex() and oct() functions, respectively:

Python
>>> hex(42)
'0x2a'
>>> oct(42)
'0o52'

Notice how the hexadecimal system, which is base sixteen, takes advantage of letters A through F to augment the set of available digits. The octal literals in other programming languages are usually prefixed with plain zero, which might be confusing. Python explicitly forbids such literals to avoid making a mistake:

Python
>>> 052
  File "<stdin>", line 1
SyntaxError: leading zeros in decimal integer literals are not permitted;
use an 0o prefix for octal integers

You can express the same value in different ways using any of the mentioned integer literals:

Python
>>> 42 == 0b101010 == 0x2a == 0o52
True

Choose the one that makes the most sense in context. For example, it’s customary to express bitmasks with hexadecimal notation. On the other hand, the octal literal is rarely seen these days.

All numeric literals in Python are case insensitive, so you can prefix them with either lowercase or uppercase letters:

Python
>>> 0b101 == 0B101
True

This also applies to floating-point number literals that use scientific notation as well as complex number literals.

Converting Binary to int

Once you have your bit string ready, you can get its decimal representation by taking advantage of a binary literal:

Python
>>> 0b101010
42

This is a quick way to do the conversion while working inside the interactive Python interpreter. Unfortunately, it won’t let you convert bit sequences synthesized at runtime because all literals need to be hard-coded in the source code.

Calling int() with two arguments will work better in the case of dynamically generated bit strings:

Python
>>> int("101010", 2)
42
>>> int("cafe", 16)
51966

The first argument is a string of digits, while the second one determines the base of the numeral system. Unlike a binary literal, a string can come from anywhere, even a user typing on the keyboard. For a deeper look at int(), you can expand the box below.

There are other ways to call int(). For example, it returns zero when called without arguments:

Python
>>> int()
0

This feature makes it a common pattern in the defaultdict collection, which needs a default value provider. Take this as an example:

Python
>>> from collections import defaultdict
>>> word_counts = defaultdict(int)
>>> for word in "A sentence with a message".split():
...     word_counts[word.lower()] += 1
...
>>> dict(word_counts)
{'a': 2, 'sentence': 1, 'with': 1, 'message': 1}

Here, int() helps to count words in a sentence. It’s called automatically whenever defaultdict needs to initialize the value of a missing key in the dictionary.

Another popular use of int() is typecasting. For example, when you pass int() a floating-point value, it truncates the value by removing the fractional component:

Python
>>> int(3.14)
3

When you give it a string, it tries to parse out a number from it:

Python
>>> int(input("Enter your age: "))
Enter your age: 42
42

In general, int() will accept an object of any type as long as it defines a special method that can handle the conversion.

So far, so good. But what about negative numbers?

Emulating the Sign Bit

When you call bin() on a negative integer, it merely prepends the minus sign to the bit string obtained from the corresponding positive value:

Python
>>> print(bin(-42), bin(42), sep="\n ")
-0b101010
 0b101010

Changing the sign of a number doesn’t affect the underlying bit string in Python. Conversely, you’re allowed to prefix a bit string with the minus sign when transforming it to decimal form:

Python
>>> int("-101010", 2)
-42

That makes sense in Python because, internally, it doesn’t use the sign bit. You can think of the sign of an integer number in Python as a piece of information stored separately from the modulus.

However, there are a few workarounds that let you emulate fixed-length bit sequences containing the sign bit:

  • Bitmask
  • Modulo operation (%)
  • ctypes module
  • array module
  • struct module

You know from earlier sections that to ensure a certain bit-length of a number, you can use a nifty bitmask. For example, to keep one byte, you can use a mask composed of exactly eight turned-on bits:

Python
>>> mask = 0b11111111  # Same as 0xff or 255
>>> bin(-42 & mask)
'0b11010110'

Masking forces Python to temporarily change the number’s representation from sign-magnitude to two’s complement and then back again. If you forget about the decimal value of the resulting binary literal, which is equal to 21410, then it’ll represent -4210 in two’s complement. The leftmost bit will be the sign bit.

Alternatively, you can take advantage of the modulo operation that you used previously to simulate the logical right shift in Python:

Python
>>> bin(-42 % (1 << 8))  # Give me eight bits
'0b11010110'

If that looks too convoluted for your taste, then you can use one of the modules from the standard library that express the same intent more clearly. For example, using ctypes will have an identical effect:

Python
>>> from ctypes import c_uint8 as unsigned_byte
>>> bin(unsigned_byte(-42).value)
'0b11010110'

You’ve seen it before, but just as a reminder, it’ll piggyback off the unsigned integer types from C.

Another standard module that you can use for this kind of conversion in Python is the array module. It defines a data structure that’s similar to a list but is only allowed to hold elements of the same numeric type. When declaring an array, you need to indicate its type up front with a corresponding letter:

Python
>>> from array import array
>>> signed = array("b", [-42, 42])
>>> unsigned = array("B")
>>> unsigned.frombytes(signed.tobytes())
>>> unsigned
array('B', [214, 42])
>>> bin(unsigned[0])
'0b11010110'
>>> bin(unsigned[1])
'0b101010'

For example, "b" stands for an 8-bit signed byte, while "B" stands for its unsigned equivalent. There are a few other predefined types, such as a signed 16-bit integer or a 32-bit floating-point number.

Copying raw bytes between these two arrays changes how bits are interpreted. However, it takes twice the amount of memory, which is quite wasteful. To perform such a bit rewriting in place, you can rely on the struct module, which uses a similar set of format characters for type declarations:

Python
>>> from struct import pack, unpack
>>> unpack("BB", pack("bb", -42, 42))
(214, 42)
>>> bin(214)
'0b11010110'

Packing lets you lay objects in memory according to the given C data type specifiers. It returns a read-only bytes() object, which contains raw bytes of the resulting block of memory. Later, you can read back those bytes using a different set of type codes to change how they’re translated into Python objects.

Up to this point, you’ve used different techniques to obtain fixed-length bit strings of integers expressed in two’s complement representation. If you want to convert these types of bit sequences back to Python integers instead, then you can try this function:

Python
def from_twos_complement(bit_string, num_bits=32):
    unsigned = int(bit_string, 2)
    sign_mask = 1 << (num_bits - 1)  # For example 0b100000000
    bits_mask = sign_mask - 1        # For example 0b011111111
    return (unsigned & bits_mask) - (unsigned & sign_mask)

The function accepts a string composed of binary digits. First, it converts the digits to a plain unsigned integer, disregarding the sign bit. Next, it uses two bitmasks to extract the sign and magnitude bits, whose locations depend on the specified bit-length. Finally, it combines them using regular arithmetic, knowing that the value associated with the sign bit is negative.

You can try it out against the trusty old bit string from earlier examples:

Python
>>> int("11010110", 2)
214
>>> from_twos_complement("11010110")
214
>>> from_twos_complement("11010110", num_bits=8)
-42

Python’s int() treats all the bits as the magnitude, so there are no surprises there. However, this new function assumes a 32-bit long string by default, which means the sign bit is implicitly equal to zero for shorter strings. When you request a bit-length that matches your bit string, then you’ll get the expected result.

While integer is the most appropriate data type for working with bitwise operators in most cases, you’ll sometimes need to extract and manipulate fragments of structured binary data, such as image pixels. The array and struct modules briefly touch upon this topic, so you’ll explore it in more detail next.

Seeing Data in Binary

You know how to read and interpret individual bytes. However, real-world data often consists of more than one byte to convey information. Take the float data type as an example. A single floating-point number in Python occupies as many as eight bytes in memory.

How do you see those bytes?

You can’t simply use bitwise operators because they don’t work with floating-point numbers:

Python
>>> 3.14 & 0xff
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "<stdin>", line 1, in <module>
TypeError: unsupported operand type(s) for &: 'float' and 'int'

You have to forget about the particular data type you’re dealing with and think of it in terms of a generic stream of bytes. That way, it won’t matter what the bytes represent outside the context of them being processed by the bitwise operators.

To get the bytes() of a floating-point number in Python, you can pack it using the familiar struct module:

Python
>>> from struct import pack
>>> pack(">d", 3.14159)
b'@\t!\xf9\xf0\x1b\x86n'

Ignore the format characters passed through the first argument. They won’t make sense until you get to the byte order section below. Behind this rather obscure textual representation hides a list of eight integers:

Python
>>> list(b"@\t!\xf9\xf0\x1b\x86n")
[64, 9, 33, 249, 240, 27, 134, 110]

Their values correspond to the subsequent bytes used to represent a floating-point number in binary. You can combine them to produce a very long bit string:

Python
>>> from struct import pack
>>> "".join([f"{b:08b}" for b in pack(">d", 3.14159)])
'0100000000001001001000011111100111110000000110111000011001101110'

These 64 bits are the sign, exponent, and mantissa in double precision that you read about earlier. To synthesize a float from a similar bit string, you can reverse the process:

Python
>>> from struct import unpack
>>> bits = "0100000000001001001000011111100111110000000110111000011001101110"
>>> unpack(
...   ">d",
...   bytes(int(bits[i:i+8], 2) for i in range(0, len(bits), 8))
... )
(3.14159,)

unpack() returns a tuple because it allows you to read more than one value at a time. For example, you could read the same bit string as four 16-bit signed integers:

Python
>>> unpack(
...   ">hhhh",
...   bytes(int(bits[i:i+8], 2) for i in range(0, len(bits), 8))
... )
(16393, 8697, -4069, -31122)

As you can see, the way a bit string should be interpreted must be known up front to avoid ending up with garbled data. One important question you need to ask yourself is which end of the byte stream you should start reading from—left or right. Read on to find out.

Byte Order

There’s no dispute about the order of bits in a single byte. You’ll always find the least-significant bit at index zero and the most-significant bit at index seven, regardless of how they’re physically laid out in memory. The bitwise shift operators rely on this consistency.

However, there’s no consensus for the byte order in multibyte chunks of data. A piece of information comprising more than one byte can be read from left to right like an English text or from right to left like an Arabic one, for example. Computers see bytes in a binary stream like humans see words in a sentence.

It doesn’t matter which direction computers choose to read the bytes from as long as they apply the same rules everywhere. Unfortunately, different computer architectures use different approaches, which makes transferring data between them challenging.

Big-Endian vs Little-Endian

Let’s take a 32-bit unsigned integer corresponding to the number 196910, which was the year when Monty Python first appeared on TV. With all the leading zeros, it has the following binary representation 000000000000000000000111101100012.

How would you store such a value in computer memory?

If you imagine memory as a one-dimensional tape consisting of bytes, then you’d need to break that data down into individual bytes and arrange them in a contiguous block. Some find it natural to start from the left end because that’s how they read, while others prefer starting at the right end:

Byte Order Address N Address N+1 Address N+2 Address N+3
Big-Endian 000000002 000000002 000001112 101100012
Little-Endian 101100012 000001112 000000002 000000002

When bytes are placed from left to right, the most-significant byte is assigned to the lowest memory address. This is known as the big-endian order. Conversely, when bytes are stored from right to left, the least-significant byte comes first. That’s called little-endian order.

Which way is better?

From a practical standpoint, there’s no real advantage of using one over the other. There might be some marginal gains in performance at the hardware level, but you won’t notice them. Major network protocols use the big-endian order, which allows them to filter data packets more quickly given the hierarchical design of IP addressing. Other than that, some people may find it more convenient to work with a particular byte order when debugging.

Either way, if you don’t get it right and mix up the two standards, then bad things start to happen:

Python
>>> raw_bytes = (1969).to_bytes(length=4, byteorder="big")
>>> int.from_bytes(raw_bytes, byteorder="little")
2970025984
>>> int.from_bytes(raw_bytes, byteorder="big")
1969

When you serialize some value to a stream of bytes using one convention and try reading it back with another, you’ll get a completely useless result. This scenario is most likely when data is sent over a network, but you can also experience it when reading a local file in a specific format. For example, the header of a Windows bitmap always uses little-endian, while JPEG can use both byte orders.

Native Endianness

To find out your platform’s endianness, you can use the sys module:

Python
>>> import sys
>>> sys.byteorder
'little'

You can’t change endianness, though, because it’s an intrinsic feature of your CPU architecture. It’s impossible to mock it for testing purposes without hardware virtualization such as QEMU, so even the popular VirtualBox won’t help.

Notably, the x86 family of processors from Intel and AMD, which power most modern laptops and desktops, are little-endian. Mobile devices are based on low-energy ARM architecture, which is bi-endian, while some older architectures such as the ancient Motorola 68000 were big-endian only.

For information on determining endianness in C, expand the box below.

Historically, the way to get your machine’s endianness in C was to declare a small integer and then read its first byte with a pointer:

C
#include <stdio.h>

#define BIG_ENDIAN "big"
#define LITTLE_ENDIAN "little"

char* byteorder() {
    int x = 1;
    char* pointer = (char*) &x; // Address of the 1st byte
    return (*pointer > 0) ? LITTLE_ENDIAN : BIG_ENDIAN;
}

void main() {
    printf("%s\n", byteorder());
}

If the value comes out higher than zero, then the byte stored at the lowest memory address must be the least-significant one.

Once you know the native endianness of your machine, you’ll want to convert between different byte orders when manipulating binary data. A universal way to do so, regardless of the data type at hand, is to reverse a generic bytes() object or a sequence of integers representing those bytes:

Python
>>> big_endian = b"\x00\x00\x07\xb1"
>>> bytes(reversed(big_endian))
b'\xb1\x07\x00\x00'

However, it’s often more convenient to use the struct module, which lets you define standard C data types. In addition to this, it allows you to request a given byte order with an optional modifier:

Python
>>> from struct import pack, unpack
>>> pack(">I", 1969)  # Big-endian unsigned int
b'\x00\x00\x07\xb1'
>>> unpack("<I", b"\x00\x00\x07\xb1")  # Little-endian unsigned int
(2970025984,)

The greater-than sign (>) indicates that bytes are laid out in the big-endian order, while the less-than symbol (<) corresponds to little-endian. If you don’t specify one, then native endianness is assumed. There are a few more modifiers, like the exclamation mark (!), which signifies the network byte order.

Network Byte Order

Computer networks are made of heterogeneous devices such as laptops, desktops, tablets, smartphones, and even light bulbs equipped with a Wi-Fi adapter. They all need agreed-upon protocols and standards, including the byte order for binary transmission, to communicate effectively.

At the dawn of the Internet, it was decided that the byte order for those network protocols would be big-endian.

Programs that want to communicate over a network can grab the classic C API, which abstracts away the nitty-gritty details with a socket layer. Python wraps that API through the built-in socket module. However, unless you’re writing a custom binary protocol, you’ll probably want to take advantage of an even higher-level abstraction, such as the HTTP protocol, which is text-based.

Where the socket module can be useful is in the byte order conversion. It exposes a few functions from the C API, with their distinctive, tongue-twisting names:

Python
>>> from socket import htons, htonl, ntohs, ntohl
>>> htons(1969)  # Host to network (short int)
45319
>>> htonl(1969)  # Host to network (long int)
2970025984
>>> ntohs(45319)  # Network to host (short int)
1969
>>> ntohl(2970025984)  # Network to host (long int)
1969

If your host already uses the big-endian byte order, then there’s nothing to be done. The values will remain the same.

Bitmasks

A bitmask works like a graffiti stencil that blocks the paint from being sprayed on particular areas of a surface. It lets you isolate the bits to apply some function on them selectively. Bitmasking involves both the bitwise logical operators and the bitwise shift operators that you’ve read about.

You can find bitmasks in a lot of different contexts. For example, the subnet mask in IP addressing is actually a bitmask that helps you extract the network address. Pixel channels, which correspond to the red, green, and blue colors in the RGB model, can be accessed with a bitmask. You can also use a bitmask to define Boolean flags that you can then pack on a bit field.

There are a few common types of operations associated with bitmasks. You’ll take a quick look at some of them below.

Getting a Bit

To read the value of a particular bit on a given position, you can use the bitwise AND against a bitmask composed of only one bit at the desired index:

Python
>>> def get_bit(value, bit_index):
...     return value & (1 << bit_index)
...
>>> get_bit(0b10000000, bit_index=5)
0
>>> get_bit(0b10100000, bit_index=5)
32

The mask will suppress all bits except for the one that you’re interested in. It’ll result in either zero or a power of two with an exponent equal to the bit index. If you’d like to get a simple yes-or-no answer instead, then you could shift to the right and check the least-significant bit:

Python
>>> def get_normalized_bit(value, bit_index):
...     return (value >> bit_index) & 1
...
>>> get_normalized_bit(0b10000000, bit_index=5)
0
>>> get_normalized_bit(0b10100000, bit_index=5)
1

This time, it will normalize the bit value so that it never exceeds one. You could then use that function to derive a Boolean True or False value rather than a numeric value.

Setting a Bit

Setting a bit is similar to getting one. You take advantage of the same bitmask as before, but instead of using bitwise AND, you use the bitwise OR operator:

Python
>>> def set_bit(value, bit_index):
...     return value | (1 << bit_index)
...
>>> set_bit(0b10000000, bit_index=5)
160
>>> bin(160)
'0b10100000'

The mask retains all the original bits while enforcing a binary one at the specified index. Had that bit already been set, its value wouldn’t have changed.

Unsetting a Bit

To clear a bit, you want to copy all binary digits while enforcing zero at one specific index. You can achieve this effect by using the same bitmask once again, but in the inverted form:

Python
>>> def clear_bit(value, bit_index):
...     return value & ~(1 << bit_index)
...
>>> clear_bit(0b11111111, bit_index=5)
223
>>> bin(223)
'0b11011111'

Using the bitwise NOT on a positive number always produces a negative value in Python. While this is generally undesirable, it doesn’t matter here because you immediately apply the bitwise AND operator. This, in turn, triggers the mask’s conversion to two’s complement representation, which gets you the expected result.

Toggling a Bit

Sometimes it’s useful to be able to toggle a bit on and off again periodically. That’s a perfect opportunity for the bitwise XOR operator, which can flip your bit like that:

Python
>>> def toggle_bit(value, bit_index):
...     return value ^ (1 << bit_index)
...
>>> x = 0b10100000
>>> for _ in range(5):
...     x = toggle_bit(x, bit_index=7)
...     print(bin(x))
...
0b100000
0b10100000
0b100000
0b10100000
0b100000

Notice the same bitmask being used again. A binary one on the specified position will make the bit at that index invert its value. Having binary zeros on the remaining places will ensure that the rest of the bits will be copied.

Bitwise Operator Overloading

The primary domain of bitwise operators is integer numbers. That’s where they make the most sense. However, you’ve also seen them used in a Boolean context, in which they replaced the logical operators. Python provides alternative implementations for some of its operators and lets you overload them for new data types.

Although the proposal to overload the logical operators in Python was rejected, you can give new meaning to any of the bitwise operators. Many popular libraries, and even the standard library, take advantage of it.

Built-In Data Types

Python bitwise operators are defined for the following built-in data types:

It’s not a widely known fact, but bitwise operators can perform operations from set algebra, such as union, intersection, and symmetric difference, as well as merge and update dictionaries.

When a and b are Python sets, then bitwise operators correspond to the following methods:

Set Method Bitwise Operator
a.union(b) a | b
a.update(b) a |= b
a.intersection(b) a & b
a.intersection_update(b) a &= b
a.symmetric_difference(b) a ^ b
a.symmetric_difference_update(vegies) a ^= b

They do virtually the same thing, so it’s up to you which syntax to use. Apart from that, there’s also an overloaded minus operator (-), which implements a difference of two sets. To see them in action, assume you have the following two sets of fruits and vegetables:

Python
>>> fruits = {"apple", "banana", "tomato"}
>>> veggies = {"eggplant", "tomato"}
>>> fruits | veggies
{'tomato', 'apple', 'eggplant', 'banana'}
>>> fruits & veggies
{'tomato'}
>>> fruits ^ veggies
{'apple', 'eggplant', 'banana'}
>>> fruits - veggies  # Not a bitwise operator!
{'apple', 'banana'}

They share one common member, which is hard to classify, but the rest of their elements are disjoint.

One thing to watch out for is the immutable frozenset(), which is missing the methods for in-place updates. However, when you use their bitwise operator counterparts, the meaning is slightly different:

Python
>>> const_fruits = frozenset({"apple", "banana", "tomato"})
>>> const_veggies = frozenset({"eggplant", "tomato"})
>>> const_fruits.update(const_veggies)
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "<input>", line 1, in <module>
    const_fruits.update(const_veggies)
AttributeError: 'frozenset' object has no attribute 'update'
>>> const_fruits |= const_veggies
>>> const_fruits
frozenset({'tomato', 'apple', 'eggplant', 'banana'})

It looks like frozenset() isn’t so immutable after all when you use the bitwise operators, but the devil is in the details. Here’s what actually happens:

Python
const_fruits = const_fruits | const_veggies

The reason it works the second time is that you don’t change the original immutable object. Instead, you create a new one and assign it to the same variable again.

Python dict supports only bitwise OR, which works like a union operator. You can use it to update a dictionary in place or merge two dictionaries into a new one:

Python
>>> fruits = {"apples": 2, "bananas": 5, "tomatoes": 0}
>>> veggies = {"eggplants": 2, "tomatoes": 4}
>>> fruits | veggies  # Python 3.9+
{'apples': 2, 'bananas': 5, 'tomatoes': 4, 'eggplants': 2}
>>> fruits |= veggies  # Python 3.9+, same as fruits.update(veggies)

The augmented version of the bitwise operator is equivalent to .update().

Third-Party Modules

Many popular libraries, including NumPy, pandas, and SQLAlchemy, overload the bitwise operators for their specific data types. This is the most likely place you’ll find bitwise operators in Python because they aren’t used very often in their original meaning anymore.

For example, NumPy applies them to vectorized data in a pointwise fashion:

Python
>>> import numpy as np
>>> np.array([1, 2, 3]) << 2
array([ 4,  8, 12])

This way, you don’t need to manually apply the same bitwise operator to each element of the array. But you can’t do the same thing with ordinary lists in Python.

pandas uses NumPy behind the scenes, and it also provides overloaded versions of the bitwise operators for its DataFrame and Series objects. However, they behave as you’d expect. The only difference is that they do their usual job on vectors and matrices of numbers instead of on individual scalars.

Things get more interesting with libraries that give the bitwise operators entirely new meanings. For example, SQLAlchemy provides a compact syntax for querying the database:

Python
session.query(User) \
       .filter((User.age > 40) & (User.name == "Doe")) \
       .all()

The bitwise AND operator (&) will eventually translate to a piece of SQL query. However, that’s not very obvious, at least not to my IDE, which complains about the unpythonic use of bitwise operators when it sees them in this type of expression. It immediately suggests replacing every occurrence of & with a logical and, not knowing that doing so would make the code stop working!

This type of operator overloading is a controversial practice that relies on implicit magic you have to know up front. Some programming languages like Java prevent such abuse by disallowing operator overloading altogether. Python is more liberal in that regard and trusts that you know what you’re doing.

Custom Data Types

To customize the behavior of Python’s bitwise operators, you have to define a class and then implement the corresponding magic methods in it. At the same time, you can’t redefine the behavior of the bitwise operators for the existing types. Operator overloading is possible only on new data types.

Here’s a quick rundown of special methods that let you overload the bitwise operators:

Magic Method Expression
.__and__(self, value) instance & value
.__rand__(self, value) value & instance
.__iand__(self, value) instance &= value
.__or__(self, value) instance | value
.__ror__(self, value) value | instance
.__ior__(self, value) instance |= value
.__xor__(self, value) instance ^ value
.__rxor__(self, value) value ^ instance
.__ixor__(self, value) instance ^= value
.__invert__(self) ~instance
.__lshift__(self, value) instance << value
.__rlshift__(self, value) value << instance
.__ilshift__(self, value) instance <<= value
.__rshift__(self, value) instance >> value
.__rrshift__(self, value) value >> instance
.__irshift__(self, value) instance >>= value

You don’t need to define all of them. For example, to have a slightly more convenient syntax for appending and prepending elements to a deque, it’s sufficient to implement only .__lshift__() and .__rrshift__():

Python
>>> from collections import deque
>>> class DoubleEndedQueue(deque):
...     def __lshift__(self, value):
...         self.append(value)
...     def __rrshift__(self, value):
...         self.appendleft(value)
...
>>> items = DoubleEndedQueue(["middle"])
>>> items << "last"
>>> "first" >> items
>>> items
DoubleEndedQueue(['first', 'middle', 'last'])

This user-defined class wraps a deque to reuse its implementation and augment it with two additional methods that allow for adding items to the left or right end of the collection.

Least-Significant Bit Steganography

Whew, that was a lot to process! If you’re still scratching your head, wondering why you’d want to use bitwise operators, then don’t worry. It’s time to showcase what you can do with them in a fun way.

To follow along with the examples in this section, you can download the source code by clicking the link below:

You’re going to learn about steganography and apply this concept to secretly embed arbitrary files in bitmap images.

Cryptography vs Steganography

Cryptography is about changing a message into one that is readable only to those with the right key. Everyone else can still see the encrypted message, but it won’t make any sense to them. One of the first forms of cryptography was the substitution cipher, such as the Caesar cipher named after Julius Caesar.

Steganography is similar to cryptography because it also allows you to share secret messages with your desired audience. However, instead of using encryption, it cleverly hides information in a medium that doesn’t attract attention. Examples include using invisible ink or writing an acrostic in which the first letter of every word or line forms a secret message.

Unless you knew that a secret message was concealed and the method to recover it, you’d probably ignore the carrier. You can combine both techniques to be even safer, hiding an encrypted message rather than the original one.

There are plenty of ways to smuggle secret data in the digital world. In particular, file formats carrying lots of data, such as audio files, videos, or images, are a great fit because they give you a lot of room to work with. Companies that release copyrighted material might use steganography to watermark individual copies and trace the source of a leak, for example.

Below, you’ll inject secret data into a plain bitmap, which is straightforward to read and write in Python without the need for external dependencies.

Bitmap File Format

The word bitmap usually refers to the Windows bitmap (.bmp) file format, which supports a few alternative ways of representing pixels. To make life easier, you’re going to assume that pixels are stored in 24-bit uncompressed RGB (red, green, and blue) format. A pixel will have three color channels that can each hold values from 010 to 25510.

Every bitmap begins with a file header, which contains metadata such as the image width and height. Here are a few interesting fields and their positions relative to the start of the header:

Field Byte Offset Bytes Length Type Sample Value
Signature 0x00 2 String BM
File Size 0x02 4 Unsigned int 7,629,186
Reserved #1 0x06 2 Bytes 0
Reserved #2 0x08 2 Bytes 0
Pixels Offset 0x0a 4 Unsigned int 122
Pixels Size 0x22 4 Unsigned int 7,629,064
Image Width 0x12 4 Unsigned int 1,954
Image Height 0x16 4 Unsigned int 1,301
Bits Per Pixel 0x1c 2 Unsigned short 24
Compression 0x1e 4 Unsigned int 0
Colors Palette 0x2e 4 Unsigned int 0

You can infer from this header that the corresponding bitmap is 1,954 pixels wide and 1,301 pixels high. It doesn’t use compression, nor does it have a color palette. Every pixel occupies 24 bits, or 3 bytes, and the raw pixel data starts at offset 12210.

You can open the bitmap in binary mode, seek the desired offset, read the given number of bytes, and deserialize them using struct like before:

Python
from struct import unpack

with open("example.bmp", "rb") as file_object:
    file_object.seek(0x22)
    field: bytes = file_object.read(4)
    value: int = unpack("<I", field)[0]

Note that all integer fields in bitmaps are stored in the little-endian byte order.

You might have noticed a small discrepancy between the number of pixel bytes declared in the header and the one that would result from the image size. When you multiply 1,954 pixels × 1,301 pixels × 3 bytes, you get a value that is 2,602 bytes less than 7,629,064.

This is because pixel bytes are padded with zeros so that every row is a multiple of four bytes. If the width of the image times three bytes happens to be a multiple of four, then there’s no need for padding. Otherwise, empty bytes are added at the end of every row.

Bitmaps store pixel rows upside down, starting from the bottom rather than the top. Also, every pixel is serialized to a vector of color channels in a somewhat odd BGR order rather than RGB. However, this is irrelevant to the task of hiding secret data.

Bitwise Hide and Seek

You can use the bitwise operators to spread custom data over consecutive pixel bytes. The idea is to overwrite the least-significant bit in each of them with bits coming from the next secret byte. This will introduce the least amount of noise, but you can experiment with adding more bits to strike a balance between the size of injected data and pixel distortion.

In some cases, the corresponding bits will be the same, resulting in no change in pixel value whatsoever. However, even in the worst-case scenario, a pixel color will differ only by a fraction of a percent. Such a tiny anomaly will remain invisible to the human eye but can be detected with steganalysis, which uses statistics.

Take a look at these cropped images:

Original Bitmap vs Altered Bitmap With Secret Data

The one on the left comes from the original bitmap, while the image on the right depicts a processed bitmap with an embedded video stored on the least-significant bits. Can you spot the difference?

The following piece of code encodes the secret data onto the bitmap:

Python
for secret_byte, eight_bytes in zip(file.secret_bytes, bitmap.byte_slices):
    secret_bits = [(secret_byte >> i) & 1 for i in reversed(range(8))]
    bitmap[eight_bytes] = bytes(
        [
            byte | 1 if bit else byte & ~1
            for byte, bit in zip(bitmap[eight_bytes], secret_bits)
        ]
    )

For every byte of secret data and the corresponding eight bytes of pixel data, excluding the pad bytes, it prepares a list of bits to be spread over. Next, it overwrites the least-significant bit in each of the eight bytes using a relevant bitmask. The result is converted to a bytes() object and assigned back to the part of the bitmap that it originally came from.

To decode a file from the same bitmap, you need to know how many secret bytes were written to it. You could allocate a few bytes at the beginning of the data stream to store this number, or you could use the reserved fields from the bitmap header:

Python
@reserved_field.setter
def reserved_field(self, value: int) -> None:
    """Store a little-endian 32-bit unsigned integer."""
    self._file_bytes.seek(0x06)
    self._file_bytes.write(pack("<I", value))

This jumps to the right offset in the file, serializes the Python int to raw bytes, and writes them down.

You might also want to store the name of your secret file. Since it can have an arbitrary length, it makes sense to serialize it using a null-terminated string, which would precede the file contents. To create such a string, you need to encode a Python str object to bytes and manually append the null byte at the end:

Python
>>> from pathlib import Path
>>> path = Path("/home/jsmith/café.pdf")
>>> path.name.encode("utf-8") + b"\x00"
b'caf\xc3\xa9.pdf\x00'

Also, it doesn’t hurt to drop the redundant parent directory from the path using pathlib.

The sample code supplementing this article will let you encode, decode, and erase a secret file from the given bitmap with the following commands:

Shell
$ python -m stegano example.bmp -d
Extracted a secret file: podcast.mp4
$ python -m stegano example.bmp -x
Erased a secret file from the bitmap
$ python -m stegano example.bmp -e pdcast.mp4
Secret file was embedded in the bitmap

This is a runnable module that can be executed by calling its encompassing directory. You could also make a portable ZIP-format archive out of its contents to take advantage of the Python ZIP application support.

This program relies on modules from the standard library mentioned in the article and a few others that you might not have heard about before. A critical module is mmap, which exposes a Python interface to memory-mapped files. They let you manipulate huge files using both the standard file API and the sequence API. It’s as if the file were one big mutable list that you could slice.

Go ahead and play around with the bitmap attached to the supporting materials. It contains a little surprise for you!

Conclusion

Mastering Python bitwise operators gives you the ultimate freedom to manipulate binary data in your projects. You now know their syntax and different flavors as well as the data types that support them. You can also customize their behavior for your own needs.

In this tutorial, you learned how to:

  • Use Python bitwise operators to manipulate individual bits
  • Read and write binary data in a platform-agnostic way
  • Use bitmasks to pack information on a single byte
  • Overload Python bitwise operators in custom data types
  • Hide secret messages in digital images

You also learned how computers use the binary system to represent different kinds of digital information. You saw several popular ways to interpret bits and how to mitigate the lack of unsigned data types in Python as well as Python’s unique way of storing integer numbers in memory.

With this information, you’re ready to make full use of binary data in your code. To download the source code used in the watermarking example and continue experimenting with bitwise operators, you can click the link below:

Watch Now This tutorial has a related video course created by the Real Python team. Watch it together with the written tutorial to deepen your understanding: Binary, Bytes, and Bitwise Operators in Python

🐍 Python Tricks 💌

Get a short & sweet Python Trick delivered to your inbox every couple of days. No spam ever. Unsubscribe any time. Curated by the Real Python team.

Python Tricks Dictionary Merge

About Bartosz Zaczyński

Bartosz is a bootcamp instructor, author, and polyglot programmer in love with Python. He helps his students get into software engineering by sharing over a decade of commercial experience in the IT industry.

» More about Bartosz

Each tutorial at Real Python is created by a team of developers so that it meets our high quality standards. The team members who worked on this tutorial are:

Master Real-World Python Skills With Unlimited Access to Real Python

Locked learning resources

Join us and get access to thousands of tutorials, hands-on video courses, and a community of expert Pythonistas:

Level Up Your Python Skills »

Master Real-World Python Skills
With Unlimited Access to Real Python

Locked learning resources

Join us and get access to thousands of tutorials, hands-on video courses, and a community of expert Pythonistas:

Level Up Your Python Skills »

What Do You Think?

Rate this article:

What’s your #1 takeaway or favorite thing you learned? How are you going to put your newfound skills to use? Leave a comment below and let us know.

Commenting Tips: The most useful comments are those written with the goal of learning from or helping out other students. Get tips for asking good questions and get answers to common questions in our support portal.


Looking for a real-time conversation? Visit the Real Python Community Chat or join the next “Office Hours” Live Q&A Session. Happy Pythoning!